Dave Embrey, Divisional Director at our product partner IKO Polymeric, provides us with a comparison between two single ply membrane types: TPO and TPE.
What is TPO Membrane?
TPO’s (Thermoplastic Polyolefin) have been extensively used within the single ply roofing industry since the early 90’s. It was developed from Polyethylene membranes which were being installed in ground engineering applications such as tunnel, lake and bund liners.
Newer versions of TPO membrane are typically now manufactured using a Polypropylene formulation. The motivation to develop a roofing grade TPO was concern across Europe regarding the environmental credentials of PVC (Polyvinyl Chloride). TPO membranes do not contain plasticisers as they are inherently flexible, and also do not contain heavy metals (which were at the time used in PVC membrane manufacture, but no longer are).
When TPO membranes were launched to the roofing industry, it was widely thought that they would eventually replace PVC membranes within a relatively short period of time. In reality, this has never happened due to the well documented shortcomings of some TPO membranes and the continued popularity of the tried and tested PVC options.
Introducing TPE Membrane a TPO Alternative
IKO Polymeric entered the Single Ply Market in the late 90’s and wanted to bring the “next generation” of Polymeric membranes to the market. They looked at the available membranes on the market such as TPO, and decided on a unique formulated TPE membrane (Thermoplastic Polyolefin Elastomer) which combined the positives of PVC (flexibility, weldability, aesthetically pleasing) and those of TPO (Plasticizer free, chlorine free, heavy metal free).
Since IKO Polymeric launched Spectraplan TPE membrane, they have successfully installed over one million metres of membrane across the UK, Europe and as far away as New Zealand. Spectraplan TPE membranes are manufactured at our Clay Cross site in the UK.
Benefits of TPE Membrane over TPO
Spectraplan TPE membranes have many mechanical and performance advantages over TPO membranes. TPE is actually a member of the TPO family, but as you will read they are very different in many areas.
1. Aesthetics of Single Ply Membranes
TPO membranes generally have a high coefficient of expansion and contraction resulting in thermal movement during hot and cold weather. This in turn has an adverse effect on the aesthetics of the membrane. The thermal movement will remain during the whole life cycle of the membrane. Generally TPO membranes are not specified on projects where aesthetics are of importance, including those projects requiring a standing seam effect.
Spectraplan TPE membranes also have a degree of thermal movement depending on the ambient temperature, but this generally occurs during the installation stage and can be greatly reduced if the recommended installation techniques are followed. Once the TPE membrane has been installed and mechanically attached around the perimeter and internal upstands, the TPE membrane starts to settle and gives a similar appearance to a PVC membrane.
The improved aesthetic quality of TPE membranes means that they have been installed on countless projects where appearance was important.
2. Installation of TPO and TPE Single Ply membranes – why installers prefer TPE
Flexibility of Single Ply Membranes
TPO membranes can be much stiffer than PVC membranes which can cause difficulty when installing and detailing. However Spectraplan TPE membranes are considered to be similar in flexibility to PVC membranes, and can be easily installed and detailed. The improved flexibility of TPE over TPO Is caused by chemically bonding the individual polymer chains, which gives an elastomeric feature to the membrane; this is not possible with TPO membranes. It is common for an installer to think they are installing PVC when in fact it is our Spectraplan TPE membrane.
Polymer & UV stabiliser content
TPO membranes typically have a polymer content of around 30% with the remainder of the membrane being made up of UV stabilisers, fire retardants, processing aids and filler.
The UV stabiliser is in the top surface of the membrane which is why the underside of the membrane is typically a different colour for identification purposes. With the UV stabiliser only being in the top surface the membrane can only be installed one way up. Installing the TPO membrane upside down, typically occurring on upstand flashings and smaller areas of field sheet, will have a detrimental effect on the long term performance of the membrane.
Spectraplan TPE membranes have a high polymer content of 60% with the remainder of the membrane made up of UV stabilisers, fire retardants, processing aids and filler. Not only does the Spectraplan TPE membrane have significantly higher polymer content it is also uniquely UV stable throughout, enabling it to be installed either way up without having a detrimental effect on the long term performance of the membrane. This significantly improves the installation experience and because there is no ‘wrong side’, avoids your installer making mistakes by installing the membrane upside down.
Membrane and Seam Preparation – No solvents required
TPO membranes can produce static when rolled out and positioned on the roof which in turn can attract construction dust particles to the surface of the membrane and more importantly the overlap area. TPO membranes can be very sensitive to the dust which acts as a barrier during the hot air welding process if not removed and can prevent the TPO membrane from welding adequately. The manufacturer will often therefore recommend the use of a solvent preparation to remove the construction dust with many requiring it prior to any overlaps being hot air welded even when just rolled out.
In contrast, Spectraplan TPE membranes require no solvent preparation at any stage of the installation or even when installed after several years. Due to the high polymer content any construction dust particles will be absorbed into the membrane during the hot air welding process and become part of the membranes filler. The only recommendation is for the use of hot soapy water on a heavily soiled membrane, which would typically be needed on older TPE roofs. The lack of solvents required improves the environmental credentials of the membrane as well as the installer experience.
Cross Joint Preparation not required with TPE membranes
TPO membranes generally have a lower flow rate when hot air welded compared to other Polymeric membranes. This results in the need for additional preparation at cross joints, consisting of chamfering the open edge of the second layer. The chamfering process ensures a sloped junction rather than a stepped junction. Failure to follow this procedure will likely result in water ingress as a capillary hole is formed within the seam. From experience the chamfering tools become blunt quickly and require regular sharpening. As a result on larger projects the standard and regularity of chamfering diminishes.
Unfortunately, if a cross joint has not been chamfered correctly then the only way to resolve this is by welding a patch repair over the affected cross joint. This then requires a further 3 cross joints to be successfully executed, trebling the risk of further water ingress.
Spectraplan TPE membranes however do not require any preparation at the cross joints. This is down to the unique flow rate of the membrane when hot air welded. The step caused by the layering of the membrane softens when heated and once rolled becomes flat and part of the weld.
In the unlikely event that a TPE cross joint is not welded correctly this can be easily remedied by reheating the top surface of the cross joint and applying pressure with the roller along the cross joint. Any capillary will be removed rendering the cross joint watertight. This is only possible with Spectraplan TPE due to the high polymer content and ability to weld at low temperatures (200°C)
TPE Membranes have a Large Welding Window
TPO welding parameters are typically 300°C (+ or – 20°C) and 3 linear metres per minute when using an automatic welding machine. If the welding parameters are not achieved due to either operator error, poor power supply, or poorly serviced welding apparatus then the TPO membrane will not weld correctly resulting in potential water ingress.
Spectraplan TPE welding parameters are typically 200°C to 600°C and up to 6 linear metres per minute when using an automatic welding machine. This ensures that the TPE membrane will more likely weld satisfactorily in more challenging site situations and conditions. A great advantage of the TPE membranes low welding temperature capability is that when working on tricky detailing such as pipes and corners the operative is in greater control and is less likely to burn or damage the membrane.
3. Repair Issues
Patch Repairs on TPO require Membrane Preparation
TPO membranes require a high level of preparation when, for example, carrying out a patch repair during the installation stage or joining on to an old roof. The TPO membrane will not only need to be thoroughly cleaned first with hot soapy water but importantly afterwards with an aggressive solvent cleaner. TPO Manufacturers would generally recommend that any patch repair is installed on the underside of the membrane if possible as satisfactory preparation of the top surface can be troublesome, especially on aged TPO roofs. In many situations this is impractical if not impossible to carry out.
Many Clients require Patch Free Repairs
TPO membranes have approximately 30% polymer content which results in any damage having to have an additional repair placed over the damage as repairs cannot be made to the membrane itself. A patch repair is typically an industry standard size of 200mm x 200mm and is placed either on top or on the underside of the membrane. The repair if installed correctly will not have a detrimental effect on the long term performance of the membrane but it will have a detrimental effect on the roof’s aesthetics and potentially the client’s faith in the roof. More and more clients and main contractors are insisting on a patch free repair, insisting on large overlays over small areas of damage.
Spectraplan TPE membranes have approximately 60% polymer content. Due to the high polymer content of TPE membranes they can be repaired without the use of an additional patch. Once repaired the membrane retains all of its original physical properties and there is little or no sign of the repair and once weathered in it will almost be impossible to see. You will, however, always see a patch repair!
In Summary: Benefits of TPE Membranes
- TPE is aesthetically pleasing and suitable for the use with a standing seam profile;
- The high polymer content makes it flexible for easy installation and simple repairs;
- TPE is UV stable throughout so cannot be installed ‘the wrong way up’;
- Its solvent free preparation speeds up installation and removes the need for the installer to use solvents;
- A large welding window speeds up welding and increases the reliability of welds;
- As no chamfering is required on cross joints, they are more reliable and simpler to carry out.
- TPE’s enhanced welding properties also allow for patch free repairs, popular with clients
SIG Design & Technology takes the risk out of roof design, offering a genuinely independent choice of waterproofing for flat, green, zinc and copper roofs. Designs are covered by our PI insurance and we’re part of SIG plc, a FTSE250 company. Our blog at www.singleply.co.uk/blog explores some of your common problems in roof design and system choice, or book our new RIBA CPDs, ‘A Structured Approach to Roof Specification & Design’ and ‘Specifying Hard Metals: Choosing the Right Product for the Project’.
